About Us

At Justin Pinder Car Rental, we believe in keeping your adventure alive. And we intend to help you do just that by providing you with the best vehicle for your travel needs. So whether you wish to cruise along Eleuthera’s vast shorelines or venture off the beaten path, we’ve got a vehicle for you!

How it works

Our booking process following 3 easy steps

Location icon
Choose a location

Let us know where you would like your vehicle to be dropped off and picked up from

Calendar icon
Pick your dates

Let us know the date range in which you would need the vehicle

Reserved icon
Book your car

It’s that simple!

Rental Deals

Get the most out of your experience

Budget icon

Deals for every budget

Incredible prices to fit your vehicle rental needs! Special offers on long-term rentals.

24 hr customer service

24/7 Support

Roadside assistance. We know circumstances are unpredictable, so we are readily available when life happens.

Map icon

Island & Boat tours

Ask us about our Seas the Day Boat Charters!

Seas the Day Boat Charters

Our Promise to You

We strive to earn our customers loyalty by working to deliver more than promised, being honest and fair and “going the extra mile” to provide exceptional personalized service that creates a pleasurable experience. We treat members of our team and customers like family and never compromise our commitment to superior customer service. It is our goal to be the best, not necessarily the biggest or most profitable, our success comes from satisfying customers on a daily basis.

What Our Clients Say

Justin is the man to talk to on "Lutra Island" for your car rental! He was very accommodating, understanding, and easy to get along with! He fulfilled all of our needs during our 12 days on the Island and was there when we needed him! I definitely reccomend his rental services, and will go to him again when we come back! Thanks Justin 👍


Justin is a class act.  Not only did he pick us up at ELH, he stopped at the Glass Window and let us roam around on our way to our house in Governors Harbour.  He also switched out our rental when one better equipped became available for our expedition to Lighthouse Point.  Then when we mentioned wanting to find fresh fish for dinner, he sourced crab claws and a fresh grouper for us.  A car rental from Justin isn’t just a car—he really was an amazing ambassador for the island and made our trip super easy.  Can’t wait to do it again this fall!

Stacy v.

Justin was amazing, he was very responsive and helpful with everything we needed. The car was very comfortable, clean and had no issues at all. I highly recommend his services. We will for sure rent a car from him in our next visit to Eleuthera.

David R.

We were happy with our car rental and service provided by Justin. He worked around our schedule to meet us at the airport for drop-off and pick-up. We had zero issues with our car and were able to get anywhere we wanted to go.

Kelly G.

Contact us

Thank you for your inquiry! We strive to respond to all inquiries within a 24 hour timeframe.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.